Pete Rose should absolutly be in the HOF!! My reasoning has nothin to do with what he did as a manager as others were saying. He is the all-time hit leader, an MVP, a World Series MVP, 17 time All-Star(at an un heard of 5 different positions) and he didn't use enhancements to do it.
On the other hand, guys like Barry Bonds, Sammy Sosa, Mark Maguire, etc. should never reach the Hall because they accomplished what they did unnaturally and used enhancements to further their stats. Now if they had not used drugs would some of the names mentioned above still accomplish what they have, who knows? If these guys make the HOF then by all means Pete Rose deserves to be right there with them!!