Ken Macha received a pink slip this week because he wasn't a players' manager. The same day, the highly coveted Lou Piniella received a three-year contract from the Cubs, largely because he was a welcome alternative to Dusty Baker, a players' manager. George Steinbrenner briefly wanted Piniella for the same reason, to replace the thoughtful, empathetic Joe Torre.
So what's the formula? There isn't one. There are only teams that need to make a change. Among the clubs in the market for a manager, the A's and Giants probably have the hardest tasks, the A's because they don't want to leap too far from where they've been and the Giants because they need to flee from their recent history.
complete article