Aah, okay - that's a whole different ballgame.
I, for one, don't really see a great deal of difference between a player's 'fantasy' worth and 'actual' worth. A player's contribution to a team is largely based on their offensive worth - a great hitter that cannot field a lick (such as Hanley Ramirez) is much more valuable to a team than a great fielder that cannot produce with the stick (such as Omar Vizquel). I do understand, though, what you are getting at.
ESPN does player ratings that factor in defense -
here.
CBS Sports does something similar -
here.
The National Pastime Almanac ranks players with all sorts of different categories and is just a great resource for most things baseball -
here.
Other than things such as this I am not quite sure what to give you. I hope these suggestions are more in line with what you're looking for, though.