[statimagician]

Originally Posted by BayAreaYankeeFan

Cal Ripken has to be one of my most overrated. Ok he played a gazillion games in a row but other than that what else did he do?

What else did he do? He hit 20 or nearly 20 homeruns in every season he played and currently has the most homers ever for a shortstop. He was also an outstanding fielder once going 131 errorless chances. There has to be a reason your in the hall-of-fame.


Statimagician baseball, fantasy baseball, stratomatic!

[statimagician]

My most underrated is B.J. Upton and my most ovverated is Juan Pierre

[Huntington08]

Derek Jeter. Very overated. David Ekstein. Underated

[Yankspwn]

I think one of the most overrated by Mets fans is Jose Reyes, his average is almost never over .300, he doesn't hit many homers, he isn't that good of a fielder, and all he does is steal bases plus he isn't even leading the league in steals this year! In all of baseball I think that the most overrated player is Jose Reyes. The most underrated player is probably (this is just my opinion) Chone Figgins, he led the league in stolen bases a couple years back. He is fast and he usually hits near .300, he is a great asset to the Angels though injuries might cause some problems.