[bigboy10182000]

Originally Posted by johnsondc

You ain't the best if you can't help your team to the playoffs. But you answered my question when you state "almost all of baseball sees Utley as the best 2 bagger in the game right now..." By the way, who is 'almost all of baseball'. Not to shake you up however, but Cano doesn't replace any of the three Yankee outfielders. Since Utley can't break into the Yankee lineup, it would be very difficult for him to bat in the 3-4-5 slots.

Writers, fans, coaches etc. To tell you the truth, I have yet to see anything or anyone (except you) dispute this.

You ain't the best if you can't help your team to the playoffs.

I guess he didn't help them. Soory, but that statement is just silly.

Do you have anything to support the argument of Utley not being able to crack the lineup?

[NatsNSoxFan]

Go ask your buddy Joek if he thinks Utley is better than Cano and who would start. Im pretty sure hed side with us.

[bigboy10182000]

Originally Posted by NatsNSoxFan

Go ask your buddy Joek if he thinks Utley is better than Cano and who would start. Im pretty sure hed side with us.

I'm sure Cano would side with us on this..

[NatsNSoxFan]

haha, yeah he probably would too.

[derek12123]

Most underrated was Joe Maur last season that guy hit for the highest AVG

[derek12123]

The most overatted has got to be A-rod even tho I love him

[johnsondc]

Originally Posted by derek12123

The most overatted has got to be A-rod even tho I love him

Arod is a give me. He is the most over rated ball player in MLB today and has been for years. The stat lovers adore him however. The people who know baseball truly know what a waste he is.

[NatsNSoxFan]

yeah w/e we've had this discussion before. why don't you give us some other bogus reason as to why Utley isn't as good as Cano and why haven't you said anything about Joek and how even he knows that Utley is better.

[SLagonia]

I'd have to go with Robbie Cano as the most under-rated. The guy was third in the league in batting average last year, and has incredably soft hands and good range. He's a four and a half tool ballplayer who is still learning.

[NatsNSoxFan]

Wow, you have got to be kidding me. Dan Uggla is more underrated than Cano. He had 27 Homeruns and 97 RBI's as a rookie with an average near .300, about .280 i think, and 172 hits. Cano had a much higher BA but significantly fewer HR's and RBI's, Uggla also almost helped his team to the playoffs, the same team that was supposed to lose 100+ games and we never heard about him. That is my final pick for most underrated, Dan Uggla.

Anyone else notice the trend with second basemen? O-Dawg, Cano, Utley, and Uggla.