It's really a tough call, between David Price and Verlander. BUT! Verlander does have 6 complete games. That's crazy. Price does have a lower ERA and more wins and less losses.. but Verlander has way more strike outs than Price. With the fact that Verlander pitched way more innings than anyone, I'm going to have to agree with you and say Verlander is going to win the Cy Young.
Everything else, you are spot in, IMO.