Easy to see why we differ...you regard good players, average players, one-year-wonders, and unproven kids all as "great".
I do not. A few of the players on your lists are "great",
but most are not....certainly not yet, anyway.
I will not live to see all your supposed "great" players
miss out on the HOF. You will.
Save your list and think about that in 30 years or so.